What do you think about PHIN’s proposal to publish all your NHS activity together with your private activity?
PHIN has opened a consultation on the proposed use of Whole Practice Data, which would bring together information about individual consultants’ activity across the NHS and independent sectors, making this publicly available.
Read the PHIN Consultation and submit an individual response here: PHIN Whole Practice Consultant Consultation
The proposal has potential benefits for patients and consultants, including:
- Giving patients a more complete picture of a consultant’s professional activity and clinical experience.
- Supporting appropriate clinical governance and practising-privileges processes.
- Reducing the administrative burden of compiling information for appraisal.
However, there are important caveats. Inaccurate or poorly contextualised data could misrepresent an individual consultant’s personal experience, competence or scope of practice, particularly where NHS activity is attributed to a named consultant, but procedures are performed by junior colleagues. NHS and private practice may also legitimately differ, as some procedures undertaken in the independent sector are not routinely supported or available in the NHS. Any combined data must recognise these differences and avoid misleading comparisons.
Although consultants may retain the option to ‘opt out’, this places an additional and unnecessary administrative burden on individual practitioners. More fundamentally, the proposals risk undermining private practice by creating a misleading or incomplete picture of consultants’ work, with potentially significant implications for their professional reputation, patient choice and the future of independent practice.
FIPO, our sister and parent organisation, is preparing a formal response to the consultation, in which LCA has the opportunity to contribute. We therefore invite our Members to share any key concerns or considerations with the LCA Office to help inform FIPO’s submission.
We also strongly urge all Members to respond to the consultation in their own right. This is an important opportunity to make your voice heard, both in relation to the potential impact on your individual practices and the wider implications for private medical practice as a whole. The proposals should not be regarded simply as a matter of data reporting: they have the potential to affect how your work is represented and understood, with consequences for professional autonomy and the sustainability of private practice.
The consultation remains open until the end of November.